patching...
Update: New! Tune in to WPIX11 at 5 p.m. to see Patch's Top Stories from the Tri-State Area.
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

Sweetooth Katonah Offers Seasonal Cupcakes With Local Ingredients

The new shop offers sweet treats and hearty muffins from a CIA-trained pastry chef.

 

With bubblegum-pink walls, playful black-and-white floors and rows of colorful cupcakes topped with satiny frostings, Sweetooth Katonah is a treat for the eyes and the taste buds.

The store has had its soft opening but plans a grander opening in the near future.

Don't wait.

Run over and try one of Pastry Chef Kaitlyn Lennox's creations: chocolate peppermint with maraschino frosting, southern red velvet with cream cheese frosting and yellow buttercake with bittersweet chocolate ganache frosting, just to name a few.

"Pastry just makes people happy," is Lennox's short answer to the question of why she took the job working with the shop's owner Stacie Calian, a Katonah resident and full-time dentist with Westchester Smile Design.

The two women joined forces to create the space at 43 Katonah Avenue and hope to serve as an alternative spot to grab a coffee and a muffin in the morning (they open at 6:30 a.m.) or a hot chocolate and a sweet treat in the afternoon (or in the morning—cupcakes have eggs, right?).

Owning a bakery and providing a new community hang-out was a dream for Calian, and is a dream job for Lennox. "I like that baking is so exact," said the 29-year-old Culinary Institute of America graduate. "But it's also ridiculously creative—it's an art and science."

Lennox brings her CIA pedigree to Katonah, along with experience at BLT in Manhattan (if you've ever had the cheese popovers there, they were once made by her) and at the Bedford Post Inn, where she met her husband, Matthew Christoff, who now serves as the wine director at Moderne Barn in Armonk. The pair now live in southern Dutchess County and have a love of all things Hudson Valley.

"What sets our shop apart is the fact that we source all of our ingredients locally, except for the sugar," she said. "Our flour comes from Wild Hive Bakery in Clinton Corners—what we have now was just milled there two weeks ago which is pretty remarkable."

And the proof is in the final product, she says, promising that the Sweet Tooth cupcakes "will taste better than anything you've ever had."

Lennox plans to feature seasonal ingredients whenever possible. This week muffins are filled with local apples and cheddar cheese, and a creamsicle cupcake will celebrate citrus season. Counter Culture fair trade coffee and honey corn and banana muffins are also on the menu.

Lennox and Calian also plan to offer food products for purchase such as Ronnybrook Farms milk and yogurt and locally produced granola. Catering is available and with advance notice, she can accommodate just about any dietary needs from egg-free to vegan. A gluten-free cupcake will be offered in-house seven days a week.

Sweetooth Katonah is located at 43 Katonah Avenue. It's open from 6:30 a.m. - 6 p.m. Mon. - Fri., Sat. from 8 a.m. - 5 p.m. and Sun. from 8am - noon.

About this column: This column features restaurant, shop and business openings and closings around town. Related Topics: Business Development, Small Business, and Sweet Tooth

Patch_comments_icon

Lisa Buchman

9:06 pm on Wednesday, January 4, 2012

I forgot to say another cool thing about what they do at Sweettooth is make muffin tops. Kaitlyn said that's because muffins can seem too big and everyone just wants the top, anyway. Anyone stop in yet?

Reply

Bea Rhodes

9:23 pm on Wednesday, January 4, 2012

Definitely plan to try them out in the next few days - looking forward to it! :-)

Reply

Sara Weale

10:26 pm on Wednesday, January 4, 2012

I stopped in today for a muffin and a few cupcakes -- very cool flavors and all were delicious!!!

Reply

mlb

4:11 pm on Thursday, January 5, 2012

Review from the kids:
1. cupcakes were not a uniform size, but all were same price. My child asked if the yellow with chocolate one was a "mini" -- it was that small.
2. the chocolate/chocolate cupcake had a funny taste, they didn't like it -- maybe too rich for kids?
3. chocolate frosting was delicious

Review from Mom:
4. Expensive (3 cupcakes and 1 muffin) -- $13.15 (I think cupcakes were $3.25 (even the "mini" one!), and muffin top was $2.50)
5. Adorable pink packaging
6. Adorable pink decor

Review from Dad:
7. Carrot cake cupcake -- delicious!

Hope they make it because it is a lovely addition to Katonah.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Kaitlyn

8:07 pm on Friday, January 6, 2012

Hello mlb!
I'm Kaitlyn, the pastry chef and first off thank you for the review! As far as the sizing, I apologize, we are still brand new and I am working on the recipe for the yellow cake so it can be bigger because I agree. The chocolate cake does have a bitter sweet ganache which can be too much for little ones, I plan on offering some with a milk chocolate frosting as well.

As far as the pricing, we know it's not for everyone, but trust me when I say the ingredients are the freshest I can find and I source locally. This means much more cost for us, but I know the taste pays off and we are really trying to support our hudson valley farmers so we can keep getting better tasting products. We will be coming up with some different pricing if you buy larger quantities and will be offering a coupon on living social soon.

I'm glad you enjoyed them and we all really appreciate your feed back.

Bea Rhodes

5:02 pm on Thursday, January 5, 2012

I bought two cupcakes this morning, planning to share them with my kids for dessert after dinner. While at lunch with friends I get a text from my son letting me know that he and his sister just ate them and they were so delicious and where did I get them. Could I please pick-up half a dozen. So, I went back and did just that – tasted a little of each before they got to them and they are delicious – red velvet I think is my favorite – not sure though, have to go and taste some more! A little pricey, but these are high end treats – I will be back.

Reply

Leave a comment