Parishioners and staff at St. Lawrence O'Toole Catholic Church are happy that the two gold-plated chalices stolen March 7 are back.
"They were returned. Thanks be to God," the Rev. Richard Gill told The Journal News.
The chalices, worth about $2,000, were taken along with a case of Communion wine, lohud.com said.
The chalices were sold to and returned by Brookfield Resources Management, a scrap metal operation in central Westchester County.
The Putnam County Sheriff's Office is continuing its investigation into the burglary.